About 12 percent of the total global energy demand comes from heating and cooling homes and businesses. A new study suggests that using underground water to maintain comfortable temperatures could reduce consumption of natural gas and electricity in this sector by 40 percent in the U.S. The strategy, known as aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES), may also help avoid blackouts brought on by high power demand during extreme weather conditions.
“We need storage to absorb the fluctuating energy from solar and wind, and most people are interested in batteries and other kinds of electrical storage. But we were wondering whether there’s any opportunity to use geothermal energy storage, because heating and cooling are such a predominant part of the energy demand for buildings,” said first author A. T. D. Perera, a former postdoctoral researcher at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab), now at Princeton University’s Andlinger Center for Energy and Environment.
“We found that, with ATES, a huge amount of energy can be stored, and it can be stored for a long period of time,” Perera said. “As a result, the heating and cooling energy demand during extreme hot or cold periods can be met without adding an additional burden on the grid, making urban energy infrastructure more resilient.”.
“To absorb the fluctuating energy from solar and wind, we need storage, and most people are interested in batteries and other forms of electrical storage. Yet, because heating and cooling account for such a large portion of building energy consumption, we wondered if geothermal energy storage might be used.”
A.T.D Perera, a former postdoctoral researcher at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab),
The study, published this week in Applied Energy, is one of the first examinations of how ATES could fit into the larger goal of decarbonizing U.S. energy systems by storing intermittent renewable energy to use when the sun isn’t shining and the turbines aren’t spinning.
After building a comprehensive technological and economic simulation of an energy system, the authors found that ATES is a compelling option for heating and cooling energy storage that, alongside other technologies such as batteries, could help end our reliance on fossil fuel-derived backup power and enable a fully renewable grid.
Aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES) uses naturally occurring underground water to store energy that can be used to heat and cool buildings. When paired with wind and solar energy, ATES becomes a zero-carbon option for temperature regulation. These illustrations show how the water is moved upward for heating in the hot months, then pumped back down and stored until winter, when the (still) warm water is brought back up to heat buildings. The same process occurs in winter, leading to the storage of cold water for use in the summer months. Credit: Jenny Nuss/Berkeley Lab
Putting thermodynamics to work
ATES is a delightfully simple concept that leverages the heat-absorbing property of water and the natural geological features of the planet. You merely pump water from already-existing underground reservoirs up and heat it at the surface in the summer with ambient heat, excess solar energy, or any time of the year with wind. It is then pumped back down.
“It actually stays fairly hot because the Earth is a pretty good insulator,” explained co-author Peter Nico, deputy director of the Energy Geosciences Division at Berkeley Lab and lead of the Resilient Energy, Water, and Infrastructure Domain.
“So then when you pull it up in the winter, months later, that water’s way hotter than the ambient air, and you can use it to heat your buildings. Or vice versa, you can pull up water and let it cool, and then you can put it back down and store it until you need cooling during the hot summer months. It’s a way of storing energy as heat underground.”.
In the U.S., ATES is still not widely utilized, though it is gaining recognition internationally, most notably in the Netherlands. One major perk is that these systems get “free” thermal energy from seasonal temperature changes, which can be bolstered by the addition of artificial heating and cooling generated by electricity.
As such, they perform very well in areas with large seasonal fluctuations but have the potential to work anywhere, so long as there is wind or solar to hook up to. Regarding additional effects, ATES systems are made to not interfere with important drinking water resources (often, the water used comes from deeper aquifers than the drinking water supply) and do not add any chemicals to the water.
How does it function?
To get some concrete numbers estimating how much energy ATES could save on the U.S. grid and how much it would cost to deploy, the team designed a case study using a computational model of a neighborhood in Chicago. A simulation of an energy grid with a variety of potential energy sources and storage options, including ATES, was connected to this virtual neighborhood, which was made up of 58 two-story, single-family homes with typical residential heating and cooling.
Future climate projections were used to understand how much of the neighborhood’s total energy budget is currently taken up by heating and cooling demands and how this might change in the future. Finally, a microgrid simulation was designed for the neighborhood that included renewable energy technologies and ATES to evaluate the technoeconomic feasibility and climate resilience.
Putting all these factors together into one model would not have been possible without the team’s diverse expertise across the energy geosciences, climate science, and building science fields.
The results showed that adding ATES to the grid could reduce consumption of petroleum products by up to 40 percent, though it would cost 15 to 20 percent more than existing energy storage technologies.
“But, on the other hand, energy storage technologies are having sharp cost reductions, and after just a few years of developing ATES, we could easily break even. That’s why it’s quite important that we start to invest in this research and start building real-world prototype systems,” said Perera.
“ATES does not need space compared with above-ground tank-based water or ice storage systems.” “ATES is also more efficient and can scale up for large community cooling or heating compared with traditional geothermal heat pump systems that rely on heat transfer with the underground earth soil,” added Tianzhen Hong, a co-author and senior scientist at the Building Technology and Urban Systems Division.
Another major benefit of ATES is that it will become more efficient as weather becomes more extreme in the coming years due to climate change. The hotter summers and harsher winters predicted by the world’s leading climate models will have many downsides, but one upside is that they could supercharge the amount of free thermal energy that can be stored with ATES. “It’s making lemonade, right? If you’re going to have these extreme heat events, you might as well store some of that heat for when you have the extreme cold events,” said Nico.
ATES will also make the future grid more resilient to outages caused by high power demands during heat waves, which happen quite often these days in many high-population U.S. areas, including Chicago, because ATES-driven cooling uses far less electricity than air conditioners; it only needs enough power to pump the water around.
“It’s very much a realistic thing to do, and this work was really about showing its value and how the costs can be offset,” said Nico. “This technology is ready to go, so to speak. We just need to do it.”.
More information: A.T.D. Perera et al, Enhancing flexibility for climate change using seasonal energy storage (aquifer thermal energy storage) in distributed energy systems, Applied Energy (2023). DOI: 10.1016/j.apenergy.2023.120957
